- Joined
- Dec 18, 2016
- Messages
- 709
- Reaction score
- 314
@Black Noise am creating this thread for if we need to talk to each other or if the admins wanna talk to us.
We discussed it after it was reported. Yet as far as I understand we are still at an impasse. I am not sure what BNs exact argument against my post is. Therefore I am going to state my argument in support of my post and let it go as it goes.
My argument centers around three facts
Fact 1: nothing about the way BN wrote his defence is vague.
Fact 2: the force pull was always specifically mentioned as being targeted at BNs feet.
Fact 3: BNs defence was to crouch but he did nothing to disrupt my force pull.
I don't feel bns defence would've allowed him to resist the force pull, so I wrote my post as If the Force pull was not resisted. I asked for several different opinions regarding the situation to ensure that my feelings were not biased by my own desire for victory before I wrote my post and I did not receive even one opinion that was counter to mine. I realize that doesn't matter because it is solely your decision. I only point this out to illustrate that this went beyond me simply deciding that his defense wouldn't work.
I asked whether I should say something to BN, or write my post the way I wrote it. I was told to write it and accept a ruling if one was required. I reviewed the rules. They do not require me to tell someone that their defence wouldn't work. The rules tell you not to exploit vagueness. I still dealt with BNs attacks fairly and BN is not in a position where he is defenseless. No auto hit occurred. I feel my post is squarely and fairly within the rules.
Please make sure the Jedi Mission threads you started before the death are finished. Thanks!I am going to OOC stipulate that Airen was killed by BNs last attack. As soon as the threads I started with her prior to this thread are finished, I will submit her to archive.